Complaints Rise as Newcomers Flock Into Fungus-Removal Work;
How to Get Rid of It Yourself
By MICHELLE HIGGINS, Staff Reporter of
THE WALL STREET JOURNAL
Seven months ago, David Barr was repairing heating and
air-conditioning units in New York City. But he decided a better
future lay in mold. "I think there's a good growth opportunity," he
says.
Now Mr. Barr is a mold inspector and remediator who charges about $125
to test mold in people's homes. He took a $1,000 home-study course he
found on the Internet and passed a multiple-choice exam, plus a quiz
over the phone. He even has a mold-inspector badge, issued by a group
called the Certified Mold Inspectors & Contractors Institute. "We did
a lot of research and study," during the course, says Mr. Barr, who
feels he is qualified to do mold cleanup.
As individual homeowners try to get a grip on their mold problems,
state attorneys general and consumer groups say they are seeing a
stream of complaints about botched cleanup jobs done by inexperienced
workers. The problem has gotten serious enough that several states are
working on regulations and licensing requirements for mold-inspection
and -remediation companies.
Currently, there are no federal or state regulations, and mold
companies aren't required to be licensed or certified.
"My nail technician is more regulated" than mold cleaners, says
Melinda Ballard, head of Policyholders of America, a nonprofit group
in Austin, Texas. "There's something wrong with that." Ms. Ballard
started the organization, which helps people file insurance claims,
after winning a mold-related lawsuit against an insurer.
Such suits helped give rise to a flood of mold claims and to so-called
mold remediation -- an industry that was virtually nonexistent a few
years ago. Lured by the promise of fatter paychecks, workers with
minimal training soon started billing themselves as mold remediators.
There are now between 10,000 and 20,000 mold-removal companies in the
country, according to the Indoor Air Quality Association, which offers
a mold-cleanup training program.
Mold remediation can cost anywhere from several hundred dollars to
more than $100,000 depending on the scope of the problem. And since
almost every major insurer now excludes mold from standard policies,
many consumers must pay out of their own pockets.
The proliferation of new companies has led to a number of horror
stories. When Kase Velasco's kitchen sink started leaking, his insurer
dispatched a company to clean up the water and black mold that had
spread on the wall behind the sink. Mr. Velasco, his wife, and two
children packed up and moved out of their Houston home and into a
nearby apartment while the mold cleanup company took apart their house
to eradicate the fungus.
Seven months, and about $22,000 in insurance money later, the family
moved back. So did the mold. A round of testing showed mold levels
were actually higher than when they left. He learned that the company
hired to get rid of the mold had been in the roofing business just six
months before.
"All they were was glorified demolition guys," says Mr. Velasco, a
commercial-real-estate developer, who declined to name the company.
Mold Relief Inc., a nonprofit organization in Norman, Okla., that
offers assistance to families affected by indoor mold, has received
dozens of complaints from California to Oklahoma to Virginia about
improper inspections or cleanup jobs. "I get calls from everywhere,"
says Elisa Larkin, executive director of Mold Relief. Companies come
in to people's homes, she says, "and a week later there's mushrooms
growing in the carpet."
Mold Restoration
Last month, Mold Restoration Inc., a mold-remediation company,
agreed to pay upward of $800,000 for restitution to consumers in a
settlement of a lawsuit brought two years go by then Texas Attorney
General John Cornyn on behalf of half a dozen consumers. The suit
alleged that the company left homeowners with unfinished restoration
work meant to correct severe mold. An attorney for Mold Restoration
says the company didn't admit any wrongdoing. Since June of 2002 the
Attorney General's office has received nearly 200 other complaints
against various mold-remediation companies.
At least two states -- Louisiana and Texas -- have enacted legislation
that would require some form of licensing or registration for anyone
involved with mold inspection, analysis or cleanup, though much of the
details are still being worked out.
Several other states, and at least one federal lawmaker, have
introduced bills that seek to research and establish standards
regarding mold identification and remediation.
Part of the problem with trying to establish regulatory practices
around mold is there are no standards for acceptable levels of mold
inside a home. Molds are part of the natural environment and can be
found practically everywhere. Different people have different
sensitivities to molds. When testing is done, it usually just compares
the levels and types of mold spores found inside the home with those
on the outside.
If the moldy area is less than 10 square feet, you can usually clean
it up yourself. If the moldy area is larger, or if you smell mold but
can't see it, you should hire someone to do the cleanup. Experts
advise that homeowners check with local consumer affairs agencies and
the Better Business Bureau before engaging a testing or remediation
company. Ask a company for examples of removal experience and check
references. And avoid conflicts of interest by not hiring the same
company to do both the inspection and remediation.