BRECKENRIDGE - Ski-resort officials on Wednesday ordered the
evacuation of about 300 residents of a 3-year-old, $21 million
employee-housing complex after an outbreak of mold reached epidemic
proportions.
With Breckenridge Ski Resort set to open Friday, residents of all 180
units of the Breckenridge Terrace apartments - mostly ski- area
employees and low-paid laborers - are being told they must leave by
the end of the month. Many will have to seek market- cost housing at a
particularly competitive time of year.
"The experts have told us there is enough evidence of mold across all
the units that we are taking this precautionary step. It's time for
everyone to move out," said Rick Smith, vice president for human
resources at Vail Resorts, the ski-resort company that owns the
apartment complex along with the Summit Housing Authority.
Smith broke the news Wednesday night to about 75 visibly upset
residents at the community's clubhouse, saying the evacuation was a
safety issue.
"We've got two weeks to find a place. You see all these people? Where
can we go?" said Hugo Victor, who lives in a unit with his wife and
3-month-old daughter.
Vail Resorts is offering its long- term employees dormitory-style
housing at nearby Keystone and is attempting to secure master leases
for other apartments.
But officials say as many as half the residents will have to find
housing on their own.
"The only good news in this whole stinking thing is we're in the
softest market for real estate that we've seen in a decade," Smith
said.
Like many parents in the complex, Rhonda Marshall worried that she
would have to transfer her 6-year-old son from Upper Blue Elementary
School.
"We've built a whole life around living here," she said.
Many
residents expressed doubt that they can find nearby housing for
comparable prices - as little as $750 a month for a one-bedroom,
one-bath apartment in a notoriously high-rent district - and some
questioned the timing of the announcement, given that mold has been a
concern for two years.
"You actually knew we had a problem before," said bank employee Kelli
Cole, who signed a lease for a year in September along with a separate
rider holding her responsible for any incidental mold discovered.
Smith, however, said the extent of the problem was unknown until this
week and that officials will have to shut down the entire 17- building
complex because of health liabilities.
"It's certainly not something that we want to do," he told the crowd.
No specific health problems have been associated with the current mold
outbreak. But when disturbed, mold spores can exacerbate respiratory
problems or cause allergic reactions, said Joan Wickersheim, a
hygienist with Denver-based A.G. Wassenaar Inc. who was brought in to
examine the units.
"At this point, we don't feel that there is a serious health-hazard
issue at Breck Terrace," she said. "Everyone has a different response
to mold and mold spores."
Noting that mold spores are omnipresent despite the arid mountain
environment, Wickersheim said the problem can have several causes, all
resulting in moisture accumulation on paper-lined drywall, particle
board and wood.
The tasteful wood-trimmed units opened in 2001 to great fanfare, as
Vail Resorts set the industry standard in providing high-quality
housing to employees.
But mold was discovered in spots only a year later, and the problem
has grown so bad in recent weeks that residents routinely were finding
it on walls and in carpets.
"It's disappointing when you spend this kind of money and try to
provide living accommodations for our employees and make such a
positive difference in our community," Smith said. "It's
disheartening."
Residents could be displaced for six months to a year while officials
try to determine the cause of the mold growth and then fix it through
costly efforts such as ripping out and replacing walls, insulation,
drywall and floorboards.
Ed Fronapfel, a forensic engineer with Professional Investigative
Engineers of Westminster, said that in recent years, homebuilders have
learned to construct "tighter" buildings for energy efficiency, but
work crews have not kept pace with better water-prevention techniques.
"We truly see it on all ranges of houses, residential and commercial,"
he said. "You're dealing with the same crews, the same subtrades. They
flash a window wrong on a production house the same way they do it on
a custom house."
Additionally, the problem can be worse in the mountains because
buildings kept comfortably warm on the inside "sweat" when surrounded
by the cold outside air, much the way condensation forms on the glass
of a cold drink on a hot day.
"Really, what we're building are terrariums," Fronapfel said. "We
build tight houses and put very humid things inside them. ... We're
not thinking, 'If we put this humid air in the houses, we have to get
it out."'
When the latest outbreak was discovered two weeks ago, officials
offered employees in units with visible mold the opportunity to stay
temporarily in the resort-owned Breckenridge Mountain Lodge, and even
provided them with free meals because there are no cooking facilities.
But with the ski season fast approaching, even those 120 displaced
residents now must move out of the upscale hotel.
Vail officials say they are working with the original construction
contractors to determine the causes and come up with a plan to fix
them, which could cost millions of dollars.
"This was not cheap employee housing," Smith said. "We need to ...
develop a long-term fix. Once we do that, we'll figure out how much
and how long, and our legal folks are trying to figure out who pays."